U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio
How personal injury cases have gone in this federal court: how many are filed, how few reach trial, who wins there and how long it takes, with the judges and the large litigations now before it. See also Ohio.
Personal injury cases
Federal courts hear a small share of injury cases, mostly those between people from different states or against the federal government. These figures cover every federal case of this type in this court, calculated from the Federal Judicial Center's case database.
- 151 Cases filed Computed 2025
- 114 Cases closed Computed 2025
- 0 Decided at trial Computed 2025
- Not available Plaintiff win share at trial
- 397 days Median time from filing to closing Computed 2016 to 2025, based on 1,156 cases
- 37% Recorded as settled Computed 2016 to 2025, based on 1,156 cases. Courts record this unevenly; it understates settlements
Not counted above: 471 cases closed in 2025 that were part of multidistrict litigation, where thousands of similar claims are gathered before one judge. They are left out because one mass litigation can swamp every other figure.
Federal cases filed per year
Computed2015 to 2025
Show these numbers as a table
| Year | Federal cases filed per year |
|---|---|
| 2015 | 120 |
| 2016 | 375 |
| 2017 | 145 |
| 2018 | 166 |
| 2019 | 220 |
| 2020 | 148 |
| 2021 | 150 |
| 2022 | 118 |
| 2023 | 137 |
| 2024 | 133 |
| 2025 | 151 |
| Case type | Cases resolved | Decided at trial | Share decided at trial | Plaintiff win share at trial | Median time to closing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Motor vehicle | 270 | 4 | 1.5% | Not available | 383 days |
| Medical malpractice | 94 | 4 | 4.3% | Not available | 481 days |
| Product liability | 159 | 1 | 0.6% | Not available | 307 days |
| Health care and pharmaceutical product liability | 61 | 0 | 0% | Not available | 461 days |
| Motor vehicle product liability | 18 | 1 | Not available | Not available | 334 days |
| Marine | 4 | 0 | Not available | Not available | Not available |
| Aviation | 6 | 0 | Not available | Not available | Not available |
| Railroad employee injury | 41 | 1 | 2.4% | Not available | 816 days |
| Assault, libel and slander | 54 | 1 | 1.9% | Not available | 199 days |
| Other personal injury | 449 | 3 | 0.7% | Not available | 399 days |
All figures in this table are Computed. "Not available" means too few cases to calculate a meaningful share or median (fewer than 20 for a share, fewer than 10 for a median). "Resolved" leaves out cases transferred or sent back to another court.
Class actions filed in this court
Civil cases the court recorded as including class action allegations when they were filed, of every kind, not only injury cases. In 2025, 127 were filed here.
Cases filed with class action allegations per year, Southern District of Ohio
Computed2015 to 2025
Show these numbers as a table
| Year | Cases filed with class action allegations per year, Southern District of Ohio |
|---|---|
| 2015 | 104 |
| 2016 | 119 |
| 2017 | 103 |
| 2018 | 119 |
| 2019 | 156 |
| 2020 | 210 |
| 2021 | 135 |
| 2022 | 141 |
| 2023 | 133 |
| 2024 | 111 |
| 2025 | 127 |
Multidistrict litigation in this court
2 multidistrict litigations are now gathered before judges of this court, as the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation reports them.
| Litigation | Judge | Lawsuits pending | Lawsuits since it began |
|---|---|---|---|
| Davol, Inc./C.R. Bard, Inc., Polypropylene Hernia Mesh Products Liability LitigationMDL No. 2846 · Products Liability | Edmund A. Sargus, Jr | 23,299 | 25,224 |
| Procter & Gamble Company "Protect, Grow and Restore" Marketing and Sales Practices LitigationMDL No. 3157 · Sales Practices | Douglas R. Cole | 7 | 7 |
All Sourced from the Panel's report. Listed by lawsuits pending, not ranked.
Judges of this court
Judges with a page here: those with at least 50 personal injury cases on file from the last ten years, and those handling a pending multidistrict litigation. Each page counts how the cases before that judge ended. Listed alphabetically; the counts describe caseloads and do not measure a judge.
- Michael R. Barrett 91 cases
- Timothy S. Black 72 cases
- Douglas R. Cole 53 cases
- James L. Graham 58 cases
- Algenon L. Marbley 87 cases
- Matthew W. McFarland 65 cases
- Sarah D. Morrison 60 cases
- Michael J. Newman 55 cases
- Walter H. Rice 70 cases
- Thomas M. Rose 66 cases
- Edmund A. Sargus, Jr 109 cases
- Michael H. Watson 115 cases
How personal injury cases tend to end in federal courts in OhioEstimated
This is our own case path model. It estimates, for personal injury cases in all federal courts in Ohio, how such cases ended and how long they took, from the 1,339 such cases the courts resolved from 2021 to 2025. The mark is the estimate and the band is its range. It describes cases as a group; it does not predict any one case and says nothing about amounts.
How they ended
- Recorded as settledAbout 47%range 36% to 62%
- Dismissed voluntarilyAbout 20%range 13% to 27%
- Dismissed by the courtAbout 21%range 12% to 31%
- Decided on a motion before trialAbout 8.1%range 4.5% to 13%
- Decided at trialAbout 0.9%range 0% to 2.1%
How long they took
- Within 12 monthsAbout 51%range 41% to 62%
- Within 24 monthsAbout 82%range 75% to 89%
- Within 36 monthsAbout 94%range 88% to 99%
Endings are as the courts recorded them. Courts record "settled" unevenly, and a voluntary dismissal often follows a settlement; the record does not say which. The endings shown do not add up to 100% because a few less common endings are left out. Federal courts only. Method: Case path model. How the model did when tested against past years.
The case path model is worked out for the state's federal courts together, not for this court alone.
Common questions about the Southern District of Ohio
How many personal injury cases are filed in the Southern District of Ohio?
151 personal injury cases were filed in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio in 2025, not counting cases that are part of a multidistrict litigation (computed from court records).
How often do personal injury cases go to trial in the Southern District of Ohio?
From 2016 to 2025, 1.3% of the 1,156 personal injury cases resolved in this court were decided at trial (computed).
How long does a personal injury case take in the Southern District of Ohio?
The median personal injury case in this court took 397 days, about 13 months, from filing to closing over 2016 to 2025 (computed). That is time in court only.
Do most personal injury cases in the Southern District of Ohio settle?
The court recorded 37% of resolved personal injury cases as settled from 2016 to 2025 (computed). That understates settlements, because courts record them unevenly and a voluntary dismissal often follows one.
Which cases does the Southern District of Ohio hear?
It is the federal trial court for its part of Ohio. Federal courts hear injury cases mainly when the parties are from different states or a federal law applies. Most injury cases in Ohio are heard in state courts, which these figures do not count.
Other federal courts in Ohio
Sources
Last updated 18 November 2026. That is the date we last retrieved the source files below.
Download the figures behind this page (CSV, 988 rows). Every row gives its label and its source. More files are in the data catalogue.
- Federal Judicial Center Integrated Database (civil, 1988 forward) File retrieved 18 November 2026 from fjc.gov. File fingerprint 74405231a9a3.
How the estimates on this page were made
Case path model. Our own model of how a kind of case tends to end and how long it takes. For one kind of case in one place, it takes every such case resolved in the federal courts there over the last five complete years and works out the share that ended each way (recorded as settled, dismissed voluntarily, dismissed by the court, decided on a motion before trial, decided at trial) and the share resolved within one, two and three years of filing. The value shown is the share over all five years together. The range starts from the lowest and highest single years and is then widened at each end by half the gap between them, because testing showed the unwidened range was too narrow: we rebuilt the model for each year from 2020 on using only the five years before it, and the share that actually followed fell inside the unwidened range about 64% of the time and inside the widened range about 88% of the time. The test results are published with the model. An estimate is produced only when each of the five years has at least 50 resolved cases. Limits: it describes cases as a group, as the courts recorded their endings. A voluntary dismissal often follows a settlement, and the record does not say which. It covers federal courts only; state courts may differ. It does not predict any single case, and it says nothing about amounts. More on this method.
The figures the estimates were built from (45)
- Cases resolved in the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 322 (Computed)
- Recorded as settled, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 179 (Computed)
- Cases resolved in the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 270 (Computed)
- Recorded as settled, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 119 (Computed)
- Cases resolved in the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 251 (Computed)
- Recorded as settled, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 106 (Computed)
- Cases resolved in the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 245 (Computed)
- Recorded as settled, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 106 (Computed)
- Cases resolved in the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 251 (Computed)
- Recorded as settled, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 114 (Computed)
- Dismissed voluntarily, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 52 (Computed)
- Dismissed voluntarily, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 62 (Computed)
- Dismissed voluntarily, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 48 (Computed)
- Dismissed voluntarily, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 46 (Computed)
- Dismissed voluntarily, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 58 (Computed)
- Dismissed by the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 53 (Computed)
- Dismissed by the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 61 (Computed)
- Dismissed by the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 66 (Computed)
- Dismissed by the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 55 (Computed)
- Dismissed by the court, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 49 (Computed)
- Decided on a motion before trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 21 (Computed)
- Decided on a motion before trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 18 (Computed)
- Decided on a motion before trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 19 (Computed)
- Decided on a motion before trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 26 (Computed)
- Decided on a motion before trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 25 (Computed)
- Decided at trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 5 (Computed)
- Decided at trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 2 (Computed)
- Decided at trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 3 (Computed)
- Decided at trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 1 (Computed)
- Decided at trial, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 1 (Computed)
- Resolved within 12 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 46% (Computed)
- Resolved within 12 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 50% (Computed)
- Resolved within 12 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 49% (Computed)
- Resolved within 12 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 57% (Computed)
- Resolved within 12 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 56% (Computed)
- Resolved within 24 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 82% (Computed)
- Resolved within 24 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 79% (Computed)
- Resolved within 24 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 82% (Computed)
- Resolved within 24 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 84% (Computed)
- Resolved within 24 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 85% (Computed)
- Resolved within 36 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 96% (Computed)
- Resolved within 36 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 91% (Computed)
- Resolved within 36 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 94% (Computed)
- Resolved within 36 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 95% (Computed)
- Resolved within 36 months of filing, Ohio, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 95% (Computed)
The full address of every source file is on the sources page. Found something wrong? See corrections and removal requests. How figures are labelled and calculated is in the methodology.