Attorneys and journalists: Newsroom Tools Search
perfectplaintiff Find an attorney
  1. Home
  2. States
  3. New York
  4. New York City

New York City

What the City of New York paid on tort claims, year by year.

Claims against New York City

These are real case records: tort claims against the City of New York handled by the City's Law Department, with the amount the City paid. Most are personal injury claims; the City's records do not separate out property damage claims. They cover only cases where the City was a defendant, so they do not describe injury cases in general.

  • 5,378 Matters closed Computed 2025
  • 3,488 Closed with a payment Computed 2025
  • $32,500 Median payment Computed 2025, based on 3,488 cases
  • $313,000 9 in 10 payments were at or below Computed 2025, based on 3,488 cases
  • $596,709,121 Total paid Computed 2025, based on 3,488 cases
  • 835 days Median time from start of litigation to closing Computed 2016 to 2025, based on 36,115 cases. Paid matters only

Median payment per year

Computed2015 to 2025. Among matters closed with a payment

$0$10K$20K$30K$40K201520172019202120232025$32,500
Show these numbers as a table
YearMedian payment per year
2015$20,000
2016$20,000
2017$25,000
2018$20,000
2019$25,000
2020$25,000
2021$25,000
2022$30,000
2023$30,000
2024$35,000
2025$32,500
By year closed
YearMatters closedWith a paymentShare paidA quarter at or belowMedian paymentThree quarters at or below9 in 10 at or below
20255,3783,48865%$9,750$32,500$100,000$313,000
20246,0803,38656%$10,000$35,000$115,000$341,250
20235,7623,75465%$8,129$30,000$100,000$323,500
20225,3803,38563%$7,500$30,000$95,000$300,000
20214,9653,34867%$6,999$25,000$85,000$275,000
20206,0923,41656%$7,036$25,000$65,000$187,500
20196,3023,82861%$6,776$25,000$75,000$200,000
20186,4263,72258%$5,353$20,000$75,000$225,000
20177,5333,93052%$6,775$25,000$69,375$200,000
20166,2123,86362%$5,500$20,000$50,000$150,000
20156,3173,79660%$5,000$20,000$47,500$125,000
2016 to 202560,13036,12060%$7,500$25,000$75,000$250,000

All figures in this table are Computed from the City's records. Payment amounts are totals for the whole matter. Of the matters paid in 2016 to 2025, 609 followed a verdict or judgment and 35,502 were settlements.

By court

Common questions about claims against New York City

How many injury claims against New York City are paid?

In 2025, 5,378 tort claims against the City were closed and 3,488 of them ended with a payment by the City (computed from the City's records). The records include property damage claims as well as personal injury.

How much does New York City pay on an injury claim?

The median payment on a tort claim closed with a payment in 2025 was $32,500, and nine in ten payments were $313,000 or less (computed). A median means half of the payments were smaller. It describes claims against the City as a group and is not a guide to the value of any one claim.

How much does New York City pay on tort claims in a year?

The City's records show $596,709,121 paid on tort claims closed in 2025 (computed).

Is a claim against New York City different from other injury claims?

Yes, in one important way: claims against a city or another public body usually have their own notice rules and much shorter deadlines than claims against a private person or company. We do not list those deadlines here. An attorney licensed in New York can tell you the ones that apply, so it is worth asking early.

Where do these figures come from?

From the New York City Law Department's own file of civil litigation, which the City publishes as open data. We keep the tort division's matters and count them by the date they closed. The payment is the amount the City recorded paying on the whole matter.

Before you talk to an attorney

Get the medical care you need first.
Your health comes before any claim. Keep the records of every visit, bill and prescription.
Write down what happened while it is fresh.
The date and place, who was involved, who saw it, and how the injury has affected your work and daily life.
Mind the deadline.
Every state sets a deadline for filing an injury lawsuit, and it differs by state and by kind of case. Claims against a city, state or other public body can have much shorter notice periods. We do not list deadlines here; an attorney licensed in your state can tell you yours.
Be careful what you sign.
You can ask an attorney to look at a release or a settlement offer before you sign it.

What to keep and bring

  • Records of your medical care: visits, bills and prescriptions
  • Photos of your injuries and of where it happened
  • Names and contact details of anyone who saw it
  • Letters, emails and claim numbers from any insurance company

It helps to know your own numbers before the first conversation. The injury claim calculator adds up your medical costs, lost income and other losses. Nothing you type is stored or sent.

Questions worth asking

  • Have you handled cases like mine, and in this state?
  • Who will work on my case day to day, and how will I hear about progress?
  • How are you paid? Many injury attorneys are paid a share of what is recovered instead of an hourly fee; ask what the share is, and get the agreement in writing.
  • Who pays the costs of the case, such as filing fees and expert witnesses, if nothing is recovered?
  • How do cases like mine usually end here, and how long do they take?

This is general information about how the process works. For advice about your own situation, speak to an attorney licensed in your state. Read the full guide to personal injury lawsuits.

Law firms

The City's records name the law firms that represented plaintiffs. Browse 918 firms.

Sources

Last updated 18 November 2026. That is the date we last retrieved the source files below.

Download the figures behind this page (CSV, 132 rows). Every row gives its label and its source. More files are in the data catalogue.

  • NYC Law Department: Case-Related Information About Civil Litigation (NYC Open Data) File retrieved 18 November 2026 from data.cityofnewyork.us. File fingerprint 7c8a2c3289a8.

The full address of every source file is on the sources page. Found something wrong? See corrections and removal requests. How figures are labelled and calculated is in the methodology.