Attorneys and journalists: Newsroom Tools Search Advertise/Partner
perfectplaintiff Find an attorney
  1. Home
  2. Answers
  3. How often do plaintiffs win personal injury trials?

How often do plaintiffs win personal injury trials?

The figures behind this answer

What each figure means

Plaintiff win share, federal injury trials: 52% Computed
Among cases decided at trial where the court recorded who won, the share recorded as judgment for the plaintiff or for both sides. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2016 to 2025, based on 2,542 cases. How it was worked out: judgment for plaintiff or both / trials with a recorded winner. We calculated it from public court records, listed under Sources.

State by state

The same figure, plaintiff win share at federal trials for personal injury (all types) cases, in each of the ten states we cover, beside the national figure. States are listed in a fixed order, not ranked.

PlacePlaintiff win share at federal trialsPeriod
United States52%Computed2016 to 2025
California39%Computed2016 to 2025
Texas48%Computed2016 to 2025
Florida51%Computed2016 to 2025
New York35%Computed2016 to 2025
Pennsylvania52%Computed2016 to 2025
Illinois48%Computed2016 to 2025
Georgia64%Computed2016 to 2025
New Jersey35%Computed2016 to 2025
Ohio42%Computed2016 to 2025
Michigan58%Computed2016 to 2025

What this does not tell you

This covers federal trials only; no recent national count exists for state court trials. Trials are a small and unusual share of cases: the strongest and weakest claims tend to end earlier. A win rate at trial is not the chance of winning a claim. A recorded win says nothing about the amount.

These figures describe past cases as a group. They are not a prediction about any one case, and what a private settlement paid is not public anywhere.

If this is about your own case

The personal injury guide explains in plain language how these lawsuits work and what to bring to an attorney. The injury claim calculator adds up your own losses, and your state's page has local figures.

Related questions

What percentage of personal injury cases go to trial?
About 1.4% of federal personal injury cases are decided at trial: that was the share of cases resolved in federal courts from 2016 to 2025 (computed).
Are personal injury trials becoming rarer?
Federal personal injury trials fell from 372 in 2015 to 186 in 2025 (computed).
What happens after a personal injury judgment? Are verdicts appealed?
Most federal personal injury judgments are not appealed. Our case tree model estimates that about 15% (range 10% to 20%) of cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff are appealed, and about 28% (range 24% to 33%) of cases ending in a judgment for the defendant (estimated).

Sources

Last updated 18 November 2026. That is the date we last retrieved the source files below.

Download the figures behind this page (CSV, 9,114 rows). Every row gives its label and its source. More files are in the data catalogue.

  • Federal Judicial Center Integrated Database (civil, 1988 forward) File retrieved 18 November 2026 from fjc.gov. File fingerprint 74405231a9a3.

The full address of every source file is on the sources page. Found something wrong? See corrections and removal requests. How figures are labelled and calculated is in the methodology.