What happens after a personal injury judgment? Are verdicts appealed?
The figures behind this answer
- About 15% Estimated share appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff Estimated Range 10% to 20%. 2020 to 2024
- About 28% Estimated share appealed, after a judgment for the defendant Estimated Range 24% to 33%. 2020 to 2024
- About 81% Estimated share affirmed, after a judgment for the defendant Estimated Range 75% to 85%. 2019 to 2023
- About 74% Estimated share affirmed, after a judgment for the plaintiff Estimated Range 41% to 100%. 2019 to 2023
- About 55% Estimated plaintiff win share at trial Estimated Range 52% to 58%. 2021 to 2025
- About 7.7% Estimated plaintiff win share on a motion before trial Estimated Range 5.9% to 9.3%. 2021 to 2025
What each figure means
- Estimated share appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff: about 15% Estimated
- Case tree model: the share of cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff expected to be appealed. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2020 to 2024, based on 1,802 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
- Estimated share appealed, after a judgment for the defendant: about 28% Estimated
- Case tree model: the share of cases ending in a judgment for the defendant expected to be appealed. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2020 to 2024, based on 5,847 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
- Estimated share affirmed, after a judgment for the defendant: about 81% Estimated
- Case tree model: among appeals decided on the merits after a judgment for the defendant, the share expected to be affirmed. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2019 to 2023, based on 1,115 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
- Estimated share affirmed, after a judgment for the plaintiff: about 74% Estimated
- Case tree model: among appeals decided on the merits after a judgment for the plaintiff, the share expected to be affirmed. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2019 to 2023, based on 150 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
- Estimated plaintiff win share at trial: about 55% Estimated
- Case tree model: among trials where the court records a winner, the share expected to be for the plaintiff. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2021 to 2025, based on 1,137 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
- Estimated plaintiff win share on a motion before trial: about 7.7% Estimated
- Case tree model: among cases decided on a motion before trial where the court records a winner, the share expected to be for the plaintiff. This figure is for personal injury (all types) cases, 2021 to 2025, based on 4,450 cases. How it was worked out: share over five years together; range from the lowest to the highest year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. It is our estimate; the method and its limits are set out under Sources.
State by state
The same figure, estimated share appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff for personal injury (all types) cases, in each of the ten states we cover, beside the national figure. States are listed in a fixed order, not ranked.
What this does not tell you
These are estimates about federal cases as a group. The record does not say which side appealed, and a reversal often sends a case back for more proceedings; it does not mean the other side won. Appeals that were dismissed, withdrawn or are still pending are not counted as affirmed or reversed. Nothing here predicts any one case.
These figures describe past cases as a group. They are not a prediction about any one case, and what a private settlement paid is not public anywhere.
If this is about your own case
The personal injury guide explains in plain language how these lawsuits work and what to bring to an attorney. The injury claim calculator adds up your own losses, and your state's page has local figures.
Related questions
- What percentage of personal injury cases go to trial?
- About 1.4% of federal personal injury cases are decided at trial: that was the share of cases resolved in federal courts from 2016 to 2025 (computed).
- How often do plaintiffs win personal injury trials?
- Plaintiffs won 52% of federal personal injury trials from 2016 to 2025 where the court recorded a winner, 2,542 trials in all (computed).
- Are personal injury trials becoming rarer?
- Federal personal injury trials fell from 372 in 2015 to 186 in 2025 (computed).
- Case tree model
- How the model was tested
- How often do plaintiffs win personal injury trials?
- All answers
Sources
Last updated 18 November 2026. That is the date we last retrieved the source files below.
Download the figures behind this page (CSV, 9,114 rows). Every row gives its label and its source. More files are in the data catalogue.
How the estimates on this page were made
Case tree model. Our own model of what happens when a court decides a case, and what happens next. It has three kinds of branch. Who wins: among cases the court decided at trial, and separately on a motion before trial, the share in which it recorded a judgment for the plaintiff. Appeal: for each way a case can end in the district court (a judgment for the plaintiff, a judgment for the defendant, a dismissal by the court, or a recorded settlement or voluntary dismissal), the share of cases that were then appealed, found by matching each case to the federal appeals database by district, office and docket number. Result of the appeal: among those appeals that the court of appeals decided on the merits, the share affirmed and the share reversed or vacated at least in part. Each branch takes five years of resolved cases; the value is the share over the five years together and the range runs from the lowest to the highest single year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. The appeal branches use five years ending one year back, and the result branches five years ending two years back, so that appeals have had time to be filed and decided. A branch is estimated only where each of the five years has at least 20 cases behind it. Tested by rebuilding each branch for past years from the five years before; the results are published with the model. Limits: who appealed is not recorded, so an appeal after a judgment for the plaintiff is not always the defendant's. A reversal sends many cases back for more proceedings; it does not mean the other side won. Winners are as the courts recorded them, and the courts do not record one for every judgment. It covers federal courts only, describes cases as a group, does not predict any single case, and says nothing about amounts or about any named judge, firm, person or litigation. More on this method.
The figures the estimates were built from (90)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 346 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 44 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 371 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 55 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 381 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 67 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 358 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 48 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 346 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 55 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 1,201 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 322 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 1,198 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 367 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 1,183 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 355 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 1,114 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 313 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 1,151 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 303 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2019: 180 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2019: 221 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 185 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 228 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 188 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 229 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 186 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 240 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 162 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the defendant, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 197 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2019: 27 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2019: 40 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 17 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 29 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 28 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 30 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 23 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 29 (Computed)
- Affirmed on appeal, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 16 (Computed)
- Appeals decided on the merits, after a judgment for the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 22 (Computed)
- Trials won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 142 (Computed)
- Trials where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 260 (Computed)
- Trials won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 145 (Computed)
- Trials where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 269 (Computed)
- Trials won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 124 (Computed)
- Trials where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 218 (Computed)
- Trials won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 117 (Computed)
- Trials where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 207 (Computed)
- Trials won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 102 (Computed)
- Trials where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 183 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 82 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 978 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 62 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 903 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 68 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 869 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 59 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 874 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion won by the plaintiff, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 70 (Computed)
- Decisions on a motion where the court recorded who won, United States, Personal injury (all types), 2025: 826 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 59 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 2 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 28 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 6 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 29 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 1 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 30 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 5 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 26 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, California, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 5 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 29 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 3 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 37 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 3 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 41 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 6 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 24 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 1 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 24 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Texas, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 2 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 27 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2020: 2 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 30 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2021: 7 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 37 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2022: 8 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 26 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2023: 5 (Computed)
- Cases ending in a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 27 (Computed)
- Appealed, after a judgment for the plaintiff, Florida, Personal injury (all types), 2024: 4 (Computed)
The full address of every source file is on the sources page. Found something wrong? See corrections and removal requests. How figures are labelled and calculated is in the methodology.