For attorneys, journalists and researchersHurt and looking for an attorney? Start here
perfectplaintiff
  1. Home
  2. Newsroom
  3. Methodology for reporters

Methodology for reporters

How the figures are made, in two screens. The full version is the methodology.

Where does the data come from?

Public sources only: court case records, official court statistics, government payment records and company filings. No figure comes from a law firm, an advertiser or a private database.

  • Federal Judicial Center Integrated Database (civil, 1988 forward) (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • Federal Judicial Center Integrated Database (appeals, 2008 forward) (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, MDL Statistics Report: pending MDL dockets (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, transfer orders (retrieved 12 November 2026)
  • U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, EDGAR company filings (retrieved 16 November 2026)
  • U.S. Treasury, Bureau of the Fiscal Service: Judgment Fund bi-weekly payment reports (retrieved 16 November 2026)
  • CourtListener bulk data: dockets (Free Law Project) (retrieved 16 November 2026)
  • Federal Judicial Center, Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • NYC Law Department: Case-Related Information About Civil Litigation (NYC Open Data) (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • Judicial Council of California, 2026 Court Statistics Report (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • Texas Office of Court Administration, Annual Statistical Report, Fiscal Year 2025 (retrieved 18 November 2026)
  • Michigan State Court Administrative Office, 2023 Court Caseload Report (statewide) (retrieved 18 November 2026)

What do the labels tell me?

Sourced A number quoted from an official publication, kept exactly as printed, with the page, table, row and column recorded. Each time the site is rebuilt, the number is read again from the saved copy of the publication, and the rebuild stops if it does not match.

Computed A number we calculated from public case records: a count, a share or a median. The file, the date retrieved and the calculation are recorded, so anyone with the same file can repeat it.

Estimated A number we worked out because no direct figure exists. Always a range, always with a named method, and built only from sourced or computed figures. No estimate is ever made about a named law firm, attorney or person.

What is counted in the federal figures?

Every civil case the federal district courts classify under "Personal Injury", from the Federal Judicial Center's case database. Years are calendar years by the actual filing or closing date.

  • Left out: multidistrict litigation, which is reported separately because one mass litigation can swamp every other figure.
  • "Resolved" leaves out cases transferred or sent back to another court.
  • "Decided at trial" means the recorded disposition is a jury verdict, a directed verdict or a court trial.
  • "Won" is as the court recorded the judgment. It carries no amount.
  • No dollar figures come from this database. Its publisher advises against using its dollar field.

What about state courts?

State court figures are quoted from each court system's own published statistics, for the states we have added. States define case categories differently, so the site does not compare or rank states. Where a state's figures have not been added, the page says so; the only figure offered is a labelled estimate of the share of cases decided by a jury.

Where do the dollar amounts come from?

Three places, all of them real amounts paid. Payments on tort claims against the City of New York come from the City's own case records. Payments on tort claims against the United States come from the Treasury's Judgment Fund reports. Settlement totals in some mass torts come from companies' filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Private settlement amounts are not public anywhere and are not on the site.

How are the estimates made?

Jury-trial share borrowed from states that publish it. For a state whose courts do not publish how injury cases end, the share of cases decided by a jury is estimated from the states that do publish it (California, Texas and Michigan). The range runs from the lowest to the highest of those states' shares and the value shown is the middle one. Limits: states define case categories and count dispositions differently, and the state being estimated may fall outside the range. Full method.

Case tree model. Our own model of what happens when a court decides a case, and what happens next. It has three kinds of branch. Who wins: among cases the court decided at trial, and separately on a motion before trial, the share in which it recorded a judgment for the plaintiff. Appeal: for each way a case can end in the district court (a judgment for the plaintiff, a judgment for the defendant, a dismissal by the court, or a recorded settlement or voluntary dismissal), the share of cases that were then appealed, found by matching each case to the federal appeals database by district, office and docket number. Result of the appeal: among those appeals that the court of appeals decided on the merits, the share affirmed and the share reversed or vacated at least in part. Each branch takes five years of resolved cases; the value is the share over the five years together and the range runs from the lowest to the highest single year, widened at each end by half the gap between them. The appeal branches use five years ending one year back, and the result branches five years ending two years back, so that appeals have had time to be filed and decided. A branch is estimated only where each of the five years has at least 20 cases behind it. Tested by rebuilding each branch for past years from the five years before; the results are published with the model. Limits: who appealed is not recorded, so an appeal after a judgment for the plaintiff is not always the defendant's. A reversal sends many cases back for more proceedings; it does not mean the other side won. Winners are as the courts recorded them, and the courts do not record one for every judgment. It covers federal courts only, describes cases as a group, does not predict any single case, and says nothing about amounts or about any named judge, firm, person or litigation. Full method.

Filings outlook. Our own estimate of how many cases will have been filed in a year the federal case file does not yet cover in full. For the year under way, it takes the cases already filed in the months the file covers and scales them up by how the full year compared with the same months in each of the last five years. The value uses the five years together; the range runs from the lowest to the highest of those five yearly comparisons, widened at each end by half the gap between them, and never below what has already been filed. For the year after, it carries that estimate forward by how filings changed from one year to the next over the last five years: the value uses the middle change, and the range applies the smallest change to the low end and the largest to the high end. An estimate is made only where each of the last six years had at least 50 filings. Tested by rebuilding it for each past year as if that year were under way; the results are published with the estimates. Limits: it assumes the rest of the year behaves like recent years, so a sudden wave of filings, such as a new mass litigation, a change in the law or a court closure, will not be foreseen. The latest months in the file can be revised as courts report late. The estimate for the year after is much less certain, and its range is wide for that reason. It counts cases filed in federal courts only, leaves out multidistrict litigation for injury cases, and says nothing about any single case, firm, judge or litigation. Full method.

Case path model. Our own model of how a kind of case tends to end and how long it takes. For one kind of case in one place, it takes every such case resolved in the federal courts there over the last five complete years and works out the share that ended each way (recorded as settled, dismissed voluntarily, dismissed by the court, decided on a motion before trial, decided at trial) and the share resolved within one, two and three years of filing. The value shown is the share over all five years together. The range starts from the lowest and highest single years and is then widened at each end by half the gap between them, because testing showed the unwidened range was too narrow: we rebuilt the model for each year from 2020 on using only the five years before it, and the share that actually followed fell inside the unwidened range about 64% of the time and inside the widened range about 88% of the time. The test results are published with the model. An estimate is produced only when each of the five years has at least 50 resolved cases. Limits: it describes cases as a group, as the courts recorded their endings. A voluntary dismissal often follows a settlement, and the record does not say which. It covers federal courts only; state courts may differ. It does not predict any single case, and it says nothing about amounts. Full method.

When is a figure left blank?

When it does not exist, or when it would rest on too few cases: fewer than 20 for a share, fewer than 10 for a median. The page says "Not available" and the data file leaves the cell blank. Blank never means zero.

How can I check a number?

  1. Find the figure's source in the Sources section at the foot of its page. It gives the file address, the date retrieved and a fingerprint of the file.
  2. For a Sourced figure, open "Where each sourced figure appears in the source" for the page, table, row and column.
  3. For a Computed figure, download the data file and the upstream file, and repeat the calculation described in the methodology.
  4. If something does not match, tell us.

What should I read next?

The stylebook covers wording and pitfalls. Sources and coverage lists every source file and what exists for each state.