For attorneys, journalists and researchersHurt and looking for an attorney? Start here
perfectplaintiff
  1. Home
  2. Newsroom
  3. New York City brief

New York City brief

What the City of New York paid on tort claims, year by year and court by court, from the City's own case records.

Read this first. These are real payments on real cases, but by one defendant: the City of New York. They do not describe injury cases in general. The City's tort records include property damage claims as well as personal injury, and do not separate them.

What are the headline figures?

How have payments changed?

Median payment per year

Computed2015 to 2025. Among matters closed with a payment

$0$10K$20K$30K$40K201520172019202120232025$32,500
Show these numbers as a table
YearMedian payment per year
2015$20,000
2016$20,000
2017$25,000
2018$20,000
2019$25,000
2020$25,000
2021$25,000
2022$30,000
2023$30,000
2024$35,000
2025$32,500

Nine in ten payments were at or below, per year

Computed2015 to 2025. Among matters closed with a payment

$0$100K$200K$300K$400K201520172019202120232025$313,000
Show these numbers as a table
YearNine in ten payments were at or below, per year
2015$125,000
2016$150,000
2017$200,000
2018$225,000
2019$200,000
2020$187,500
2021$275,000
2022$300,000
2023$323,500
2024$341,250
2025$313,000

The two charts have different scales. Amounts are in the dollars of the year the matter closed and are not adjusted for prices.

How often does the City pay?

Share of closed tort matters on which the City paid, per year

Computed2015 to 2025

0%20%40%60%80%20152017201920212023202565%
Show these numbers as a table
YearShare of closed tort matters on which the City paid, per year
201560%
201662%
201752%
201858%
201961%
202056%
202167%
202263%
202365%
202456%
202565%

How many payments follow a verdict, and how many are settlements?

Year closedMatters closedClosed with a paymentPaid by settlementPaid after a verdict or judgmentTotal paid
20255,3783,4883,44938$596,709,121
20246,0803,3863,249137$573,889,679
20235,7623,7543,66787$583,778,472
20225,3803,3853,31867$484,243,057
20214,9653,3483,3378$500,331,206
20206,0923,4163,40214$332,069,063
20196,3023,8283,77648$423,876,035
20186,4263,7223,65369$455,920,512
20177,5333,9303,84287$429,969,974
20166,2123,8633,80954$384,342,653
20156,3173,7963,72273$275,150,916

All Computed from the City's records. The two "paid by" columns use the City's recorded disposition; a small number of paid matters carry neither.

How do the five county Supreme Courts compare?

Tort matters against the City, 2016 to 2025 combined
CourtMatters closedClosed with a paymentShare paidMedian payment9 in 10 at or below
Bronx County 13,9049,68670%$32,500$225,000
Kings County (Brooklyn) 15,0897,74751%$40,000$375,000
New York County (Manhattan) 10,9425,76653%$45,000$375,000
Queens County 8,4994,44252%$35,000$300,000
Richmond County (Staten Island) 2,3161,69773%$45,000$300,000
All courts, citywide60,13036,12060%$25,000$250,000

All Computed. Courts are listed alphabetically, not ranked. The citywide row also includes matters in other courts, such as Civil Court and federal court. Differences between courts reflect the mix of claims heard there as well as anything about the court.

What do the records leave out?

Download the data

Column lists, sources and dates for every file are in the data catalogue.

The full page is New York City claims. See also the New York state brief.

Press contact

Questions about a figure, a request for a cut of the data, or an interview request: use the press form, or email [email protected].

To report an error in a figure, see corrections and removal requests.

Sources

Last updated 18 November 2026. That is the date we last retrieved the source files below.

  • NYC Law Department: Case-Related Information About Civil Litigation (NYC Open Data) File retrieved 18 November 2026 from data.cityofnewyork.us. File fingerprint 7c8a2c3289a8.

The full address of every source file is on the sources page. Found something wrong? See corrections and removal requests. How figures are labelled and calculated is in the methodology.