Stylebook
How to describe these figures so that what you write is true. Definitions, wording that holds up, and the mistakes that are easiest to make.
Jump to: the three labels · phrases to use and avoid · pitfalls · measures · case types
What do the three labels mean for my copy?
- Sourced
- Quoted from an official publication and kept exactly as printed. Cite the publication.
- Computed
- Calculated by perfectplaintiff.com from public case records. Write "an analysis of" the source, not "according to" the source: the source published the records, not the figure.
- Estimated
- Worked out where no direct figure exists. Always call it an estimate and always give the range. Never present it as a count or a published statistic.
Which phrases hold up, and which do not?
| Write | Not | Why |
|---|---|---|
| "decided at trial" | "went to court", "went to trial" | Every filed case is in court. The figure counts cases whose recorded disposition is a jury verdict, a directed verdict or a court trial. A case can reach trial and settle before a decision; those are not counted. |
| "recorded as settled" | "settled", "the settlement rate" | Courts record the settled code unevenly, and many voluntary dismissals follow a settlement. The figure understates settlements and should not be called the settlement rate. |
| "plaintiffs won N% of trials where the court recorded a winner" | "plaintiffs win N% of cases" | The share covers the small number of cases decided at trial, not all cases. A judgment for the plaintiff says nothing about the amount, and outcomes can change after trial. |
| "in federal courts in Texas" | "in Texas", "Texas courts" | Federal figures are not state figures. Most injury cases are heard in state courts, which these figures do not count. |
| "on claims against the City of New York" | "in New York injury cases", "the typical New York settlement" | The payment figures describe one defendant, the City. They include property damage claims and do not describe injury cases in general. |
| "an estimated $X (range $A to $B)" | "the average award is $X" | Estimates must be called estimates and quoted with their range. The site publishes no estimate of what cases are worth. |
| "the median payment" | "the average payment", "the typical payout" | The figures are medians: half were above and half below. A few very large payments would pull an average far above what most claimants received. |
| "firms named in the City's records, listed alphabetically" | "top firms", "leading firms", "most successful firms" | Firms are not ranked. Counts cover only claims against the City of New York that appear in its records, and a larger number is not a measure of quality. |
| "not available" | "zero", "none" | A missing figure means it does not exist or rests on too few cases. It does not mean zero. |
What are the common pitfalls?
Multidistrict litigation swamps counts
In multidistrict litigation, thousands of similar claims are gathered before one judge. One mass litigation can add tens or hundreds of thousands of cases to a single year. The figures here leave those cases out and report them in a separate column. Adding the two together, or comparing a year with a large mass litigation to one without, describes the litigation, not ordinary injury cases.
Small numbers
A share is not calculated from fewer than 20 cases, and a median from fewer than 10. Even above those floors, a win share built on a few dozen trials can move sharply from one period to the next. Give the number of cases behind a share whenever you quote one; it is shown beside every figure and in every data file.
Fiscal years and calendar years
Federal figures use calendar years by the actual filing or closing date. State court statistics use each state's own reporting year: California's runs July to June and Texas's September to August. The period is shown with every figure. Do not line up a fiscal-year state figure against a calendar-year federal one as if they covered the same months.
State categories differ
Each court system defines its own case categories. California's injury categories include property damage and wrongful death. Michigan groups medical malpractice and product liability with other damage suits. The count of cases decided by a judge after trial is defined differently from state to state, and some states include short uncontested hearings in it. Comparing or ranking states on these figures is not sound.
Our federal counts differ slightly from the courts' own tables
The courts publish tables by reporting year; these figures use the actual calendar date and leave out multidistrict litigation. Small differences are expected and are not errors.
Who "won" is as the court recorded it
The record of who won at trial is taken as the court entered it. It does not capture amounts, later reductions by the judge, or reversals on appeal. No dollar figure here comes from the federal case database, whose dollar field its own publisher advises against using.
Trials are not typical cases
Cases decided at trial are a small and unusual share of all cases. Figures about trials should not be used to describe what happens to most claims.
What exactly does each measure count?
Federal court measures
- Federal cases filed
- Cases filed in the year, excluding cases flagged as multidistrict litigation.
- Federal cases closed
- Cases closed in the year, excluding cases flagged as multidistrict litigation.
- Federal multidistrict litigation cases closed
- Cases closed in the year that are flagged as multidistrict litigation. Shown separately because a single mass litigation can add tens of thousands of cases.
- Federal cases resolved in the court
- Cases closed in the year, excluding multidistrict litigation and excluding cases transferred or sent back to another court.
- Federal cases decided at trial
- Resolved cases whose recorded disposition is a jury verdict, a directed verdict or a court (bench) trial.
- Cases decided at trial divided by cases resolved in the court.
- Cases whose recorded disposition is 'settled' divided by cases resolved in the court. Courts record this code inconsistently, so it understates settlements; many voluntary dismissals follow a settlement.
- Among cases decided at trial where the court recorded who won, the share recorded as judgment for the plaintiff or for both sides.
- Median days from filing to closing, federal
- Median number of days between filing and closing for cases resolved in the court.
State court measures
- State court cases filed
- As published by the state's court administration. Each state defines its case categories differently, so states should not be compared directly.
- State court cases disposed
- As published by the state's court administration.
- State court cases decided by jury
- As published by the state's court administration.
- State court cases decided by a judge after trial
- As published by the state's court administration. States count this differently; some include short uncontested hearings.
- Cases decided by jury divided by cases disposed.
New York City payment measures
- Matters closed
- Litigation matters closed in the year.
- Matters closed with a payment
- Matters closed in the year in which the government paid more than zero.
- Matters closed with a payment divided by matters closed.
- Median payment
- Median amount paid, among matters with a payment.
- 25th percentile payment
- A quarter of payments were at or below this amount.
- 75th percentile payment
- Three quarters of payments were at or below this amount.
- 90th percentile payment
- Nine in ten payments were at or below this amount.
- Total paid
- Sum of amounts paid on matters closed in the year.
- Median days from start of litigation to closing, paid matters
- Median number of days between the recorded start of litigation and closing, among matters with a payment.
- Matters paid after a verdict or judgment
- Matters closed with a payment whose recorded disposition is an order, judgment or verdict.
- Matters paid by settlement
- Matters closed with a payment whose recorded disposition is a settlement.
How are case types defined?
- Motor vehicle
- Injury claims arising from motor vehicle collisions.
- Medical malpractice
- Injury claims against health care providers.
- Product liability
- Injury claims alleging a defective product, other than vehicles, aircraft, vessels, pharmaceuticals and asbestos.
- Health care and pharmaceutical product liability
- Injury claims alleging a defective drug or medical device.
- Motor vehicle product liability
- Injury claims alleging a defect in a motor vehicle.
- Asbestos
- Asbestos personal injury product liability claims.
- Marine
- Maritime injury claims, including marine product liability.
- Aviation
- Injury claims from aircraft accidents, including aircraft product liability.
- Railroad employee injury
- Claims under the Federal Employers' Liability Act.
- Assault, libel and slander
- Federal courts group assault, libel and slander together under personal injury.
- Other personal injury
- Personal injury claims not in another category, including premises claims.
- Premises liability
- Injury claims arising from a dangerous condition on property.
- Tort claims against a government
- Claims handled by a government's tort unit. Mostly personal injury; may include property damage. The source does not separate them.
- All tort trials
- Every tort case type in the source combined, including non-injury torts such as libel and conversion.
The federal courts' "Personal Injury" grouping includes assault, libel and slander. Each source's own category codes are kept alongside these types in the data.
How should I cite a figure?
- Sourced: cite the publication named beside the figure, with its year.
- Computed: "perfectplaintiff.com analysis of" the source named beside the figure, with the retrieval date.
- Estimated: "perfectplaintiff.com estimate", with the range, and a line saying what the estimate is based on.
The key numbers page has a citation ready to copy for each figure. The full account of how figures are made is in the methodology.